Sample Policy

The following should go without saying, but due to recent foofarah about bloggers, ethics, etc., here goes:

Almost all of the wines, beers, and spirits featured on this blog I have bought myself. I expect that it will continue to be that way, much to my wallet’s chagrin.

Readers: I do accept samples for tasting. My accepting a sample in no way guarantees a favorable tasting note. When time and resources permit, I will try to taste samples I receive blind (for example, comparing to other wines made from the same grape variety, vintage, etc.) However, I can’t afford to just pop 6 bottles every weekend and taste them all blind, so some samples may be tasted non-blind (just like I taste almost everything else). Transparency is the key here and I will ALWAYS note when any wine that I review was received as a sample, whether I blinded it or not.

Producers: If you do send a sample, I will do my best to taste in a controlled environment and give constructive feedback. While sample influx is currently somewhat low, it’s pretty likely that your sample will merit a full-on review on the blog. However, since this blog’s primary purpose is education, technically interesting wines will increase the chances of a review. For example, uncommon grape varieties, novel or interesting winemaking techniques, interesting closures, or even flaws would be good fodder for a “Science” section in a review. You are encouraged to provide detailed information about the winemaking process and statistics on the wine, including (if relevant) percentage of grape varieties included, residual sugar, pH/TA, Brix at harvest, crop yield, oak regimen, type of oak, cases produced, etc. The more information I get about the wine, the better. If I determine that the wine is flawed (corked, oxidized, VA, ladybug taint, etc.), I will be sure to let you know, and I might write about the flaw.

If you’ve read all this and still want to send a sample, contact me at ithacork [at] for more information.

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)

One Response to Sample Policy

  1. [...] Note: I tasted these two wines together, blind, in identical ISO 9000 glasses. I did this partially because I received the Stoutbridge as a sample from the Hudson Valley Wine Goddess. For more details about samples, see the sample policy. [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *